Legendary Shakes
SHAKES & DESSERTS
Hand-spun specialty shakes, OMG cakes and all the Lindy diner dessert classics.
Specialty Shakes — $13.75
- Adams Avenue$13.75
Chocolate ice cream, peanut butter, Oreo, chocolate sauce.
- Fireman's Park$13.75
Vanilla ice cream, cookie dough, Oreos, caramel sauce.
- Shore Road$13.75
Strawberry ice cream, mixed fresh berries, berry sauce.
- Bulldog$13.75
Vanilla ice cream, mint, crushed Oreos.
- Montauk Highway$13.75
Vanilla ice cream, Nutella, peanut butter, chocolate sauce.
- Caramel Brownie Explosion$13.75
Chocolate ice cream, brownie, caramel sauce.
- Broadway$13.75
Chocolate ice cream, bananas, peanut butter, chocolate sauce.
- Love Potion$13.75
Chocolate ice cream, Nutella, strawberries.
OMG Cakes — $8
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake$8
Towering layers of chocolate and peanut butter.
- Carrot Cake$8
Cream cheese frosting.
- Vanilla Rainbow$8
Classic rainbow layers.
- Chocolate Overload$8
For serious chocolate lovers.
- New York Cheesecake$8
Rich and creamy, the New York way.
Lindy Diner Classics
- Chocolate Brownie$5
Add a la mode +$5.
- Crumb Cake$7
Add a la mode +$5.
- Apple Pie$6
Add a la mode +$5.
- Pecan Pie$6
Add a la mode +$5.
- Rice Pudding$6
House made.
- Chocolate Pudding$6
House made.
- Jello$5
A diner staple.
- Chocolate Chip Cookie$3
Baked fresh.
- M&M Cookie$3
Baked fresh.
- Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich$9
Two cookies, one big scoop.
- Cup of Dirt$7
Pudding, crushed cookies, gummy worms.
- Plant Based Shuga Pie$8
Fully plant based.